God is just; God is merciful.
The Gospel for the 5th Sunday of Lent takes place in Jerusalem, in the temple where Jesus had been teaching. In front of the eager crowds listening to Jesus, his enemies bring forward a woman caught in adultery, the penalty for which was death by stoning. These opponents want to use the occasion to embarrass Jesus, since he had the well-deserved reputation of proclaiming God’s mercy toward sinners. The trap is clear. If Jesus takes the side of the adulterous woman, he is open to the charge of ignoring God’s law and God’s justice. If he insists on following the Law exactly, his reputation as a prophet of God’s mercy becomes questionable.
In response, Jesus, wise and merciful, devises a way to get the woman out of the situation, saving her life and letting her begin over again. In doing so, he emphasizes the mercy of God, but he also upholds the justice of God. He does not reject the biblical commandment against adultery. We don’t know what Jesus was writing on the ground, but we do know that Jesus gives an unexpected answer to his enemies, and that response suggests a totally different way of looking at the situation. He delivers a sharp challenge, “Let the one among you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone at her.” His words have the effect of turning the accusers’ attention back on themselves, making them realize that they too are sinners. In his parting words to the woman, Jesus again manifests both mercy and justice. He first says to her, “Neither do I condemn you,” upholding the mercy of God. Then he adds, “From now on do not sin anymore.”
Jesus knows what sin is, and he does not shrink from calling certain actions “sins.” He recognizes that some actions are inappropriate and offensive both to the justice of God and to the betterment of human beings. He forgives the sinner but does not excuse or explain away the sin. Thus, Jesus upholds the justice of God.
At this point in Lent, we may need to recognize and experience both God’s justice and God’s mercy. By confessing our sinfulness and determining to avoid sin, we bear witness to the justice of God. By accepting the forgiveness of our sins and by determining to forgive those who have offended us, we bear witness to God’s mercy.
Fr. Frank Reale, S.J.